Harvard University has reached a settlement in a lawsuit filed by Orthodox Jewish student Alexander “Shabbos” Kestenbaum over claims of anti-Semitic discrimination, bringing an end to a 16-month legal battle while the terms remain confidential.
At a Glance
- Harvard’s settlement with Alexander “Shabbos” Kestenbaum brings a closure to the Title VI lawsuit.
- The case dismissal with prejudice prevents reopening of the allegations.
- The settlement terms remain confidential, reflecting mutual efforts to combat antisemitism.
- Previous claims highlighted incidents of antisemitism and anti-Israel bias on campus.
Confidential Settlement After 16-Month Legal Battle
Harvard University and Alexander Kestenbaum have agreed to a confidential settlement in a lawsuit accusing the university of failing to address antisemitic discrimination. Filed in January 2024, the case has been legally active for 16 months. The complaint focused on alleged Title VI violations, arguing that Harvard did not adequately protect Jewish students from hostile acts.
The lawsuit experienced several developments including Harvard facing severe potential federal funding cuts of almost $3 billion due to the alleged antisemitism inaction. This pressure likely played a role in hastening a settlement before the impending discovery deadline, a measure that Kestenbaum sought to avoid.
Dismissal and Settlement Terms
Kestenbaum’s case was dismissed with prejudice. This legal term prevents him from reopening the same claims. Though the precise terms of their agreement have not been disclosed to the public, both Harvard and Kestenbaum have acknowledged each other’s efforts to address and combat antisemitism, showing a commitment to fostering inclusivity and tolerance.
“Harvard and Mr. Kestenbaum acknowledge each other’s steadfast and important efforts to combat antisemitism at Harvard and elsewhere.” – Harvard spokesperson Jason A. Newton.
This settlement follows another with the group Students Against Antisemitism in January 2025, during which Harvard agreed to adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s definition of antisemitism. Kestenbaum continued his legal pursuit with renewed counsel, dissatisfied with previous resolutions.
Wider Implications and Harvard’s Response
Harvard has taken steps to enhance training and education concerning antisemitism, as outlined in the resolution of various claims against it. The broader implications of such a settlement may hold progressive strides towards ensuring religious tolerance and preventing antisemitic incidents on university campuses nationwide.
“Harvard University and Shabbos Kestenbaum have reached an agreement to resolve their ongoing litigation.” – Harvard spokesperson Jason A. Newton.
Despite these efforts, Harvard was reported to have faced additional funding cuts by the Trump administration, totaling $450 million, citing inaction against antisemitism and alleged bias against different demographic groups. These financial implications further underscore the importance of sincere institutional responses to allegations of discrimination and bias.
